Find Vacation Home Rentals
  1. Home
  2. Vacation Rentals
  3. Bahamas
  4. Eleuthera
  5. Historic Sea Captain's House, Walk to Town and Beach
FindVacationHomeRentals

Discover exceptional vacation rentals across the globe. Experience seamless booking directly with verified hosts, ensuring unforgettable stays with zero hidden platform fees.

Discover

  • Browse all properties
  • Cabins
  • Beachfront
  • City apartments
  • Cottages

Hosting

  • Become a host
  • Host resources
  • Owner login
  • Promote your property

Support

  • Contact us
  • FAQ

Company

  • About
  • Blog
  • Testimonials

© 2026 FindVacationHomeRentals. All rights reserved.

TermsPrivacyCookiesSitemap

Historic Sea Captain's House, Walk to Town and Beach

Photo 1
Photo 2
Photo 3
Photo 4
Photo 5
Photo 1
1 / 30
Photo 2
2 / 30
Photo 3
3 / 30
Photo 4
4 / 30
Photo 5
5 / 30
Photo 6
6 / 30
Photo 7
7 / 30
Photo 8
8 / 30
Photo 9
9 / 30
Photo 10
10 / 30
Photo 11
11 / 30
Photo 12
12 / 30
Photo 13
13 / 30
Photo 14
14 / 30
Photo 15
15 / 30
Photo 16
16 / 30
Photo 17
17 / 30
Photo 18
18 / 30
Photo 19
19 / 30
Photo 20
20 / 30
Photo 21
21 / 30
Photo 22
22 / 30
Photo 23
23 / 30
Photo 24
24 / 30
Photo 25
25 / 30
Photo 26
26 / 30
Photo 27
27 / 30
Photo 28
28 / 30
Photo 29
29 / 30
Photo 30
30 / 30

4-bedroom House in Eleuthera

8 guests·4 bedrooms·4 beds·2 bathrooms
Matthew Simon

Hosted by Matthew Simon

Superhost·6 years hosting

Fast wifi

Reliable connection throughout the property.

Private pool

One of the few places in the area with a pool.

LOVINGLY RESTORED SEA CAPTAIN'S HOUSE IN FRIENDLY, HISTORIC GOVERNOR'S HARBOUR

A white picket fence and palm trees welcome you to this elegant 19th century home, nestled on a quiet street among other colonial houses in historic Governor's Harbour, the original capitol of the Bahamas.

Built by Captain John Bethel of 'Sloop John B' fame, Tamarind is an airy, four-bedroom home that sleeps up to eight guests in comfort. It has a remodeled kitchen with a breakfast table, as well as a separate dining room. Also downstairs is a parlor and a second living area which we call the telephone room. Tamarind had one bedroom downstairs with twin beds that can be converted to a king bed. There is also a full bathroom downstairs as well as a lovely and private outdoor shower.

Upstairs, there are three more bedrooms, two with twin beds that can convert to king beds, and one with a king bed. There is a full bathroom upstairs.


You will also enjoy the wrap-around verandah and private back patio, perfect for sunning or entertaining.

Tamarind is decorated with country antiques, grass mats, ceiling fans and tasteful art. Its spacious garden is filled with tropical flowering plants and fruit trees. Our family has made every effort to maintain the charming grace of this historic home.

From Tamarind you are just a few steps from the town center and the sleepy harbour, with its lovely cove beaches and boats at anchor. You are also a ten minute walk or short drive to one of the Caribbean's most spectacular beaches. A one and a half mile crescent of pink powder sand, protected by a live barrier reef, with innumerable shades of turquoise, green and blue water stretching to the horizon.

Amenities include WIFI and cable TV. All bedrooms are air conditioned.

THE TOWN AND THE ISLAND

Governor's Harbour is a small, quiet town on the Family Island of Eleuthera, offering a collection of distinctive colonial homes, historic churches, and colorful Bahamian buildings. The natural beauty of Eleuthera is only exceeded by the grace and warmth of its people, a primary reason vacationing couples and families return again and again to this island community.

You will find all the services you need in town; grocery stores, gift shops, post office, banks, gas station, dive shop, liquor store and bakery. There are also several good local restaurants to chose from, and a few colorful local bars.

In addition, regular weekly events in town include a fish fry most Friday nights on one of the harbour's beaches, and a Saturday morning arts and crafts program for children at the historic Haynes Library. Most of these amenities are within easy walking distance from Tamarind.

There are no casinos or flashy nightclubs on Eleuthera: the local Bahamians prefer a more sedate, relaxed atmosphere.

The island of Eleuthera is 110 miles long and an average of only two miles wide. Governor's Harbour is located in the middle of Eleuthera, making day excursions easy. The entire island is ringed by world-class beaches, some of which you will have all to yourself.

There are many interesting settlements up and down the island. In addition, you will be able to enjoy fabulous fishing (deep sea and bone fishing), snorkeling and Scuba diving, golf and tennis. Or, you could just relax on the verandah with a good book from Tamarind's library.

 

 

Where you'll sleep

What this place offers

air conditioning
balcony
bed linens provided
dishwasher
dvd player
garden or backyard
heating
internet wifi

4 nights in Eleuthera

Add your travel dates for exact pricing

August 2026
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
September 2026
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
August 2026
SuMoTuWeThFrSa

Things to know

House rules

  • children welcome
  • no smoking

Cancellation policy


100% refund if you cancel at least 14 days before check-in.
50% refund (minus the service fee) if you cancel at least 7 days before check-in.
No refund if you cancel less than 7 days before check-in.


Damage and Incidentals
You will be responsible for any damage to the rental property caused by you or your party during your stay.


House Rules
Check in after: 4:00 PM Check out before: 10:00 AM
Children allowed
No pets
No parties/events
No smoking
Max guests: 8
Minimum age of primary renter: 23

$ 0night

You won't be charged yet

Where you'll be

Eleuthera, Bahamas, Eleuthera, Bahamas

1. Poponi Beach 1.2 mi 2. Ten Bay Beach 3.1 mi 3. OceanView Farm 2.8 mi 4. Twin Coves Beach 5.7 mi 5. Leon Levy Native Plant Preserve 3 mi 6. Queens Bath 1.9 mi

Meet your host

Matthew Simon

Matthew Simon

Superhost

0

Reviews

–

Rating

6 Years

Hosting

Response rate: 95%

Responds within a few hours

Available: Mon-Sun (8.00am - 8.00pm)

Speaks

About Matthew Simon

OASIS OF LUXURY Buttonwood Reserve offers luxurious accommodations at a peaceful retreat located in the center of Eleuthera, just 3 miles from Governor’s Harbour airport (GHB).From a high ridge over the Caribbean, the sea-to-sea view is breathtaking. The island at this point is just over a kilometer wide, and beach lovers will need to decide which of two beaches - Caribbean or Atlantic - they prefer.Restaurants and recreational options abound up and down the Queen's Highway. Yet for all the convenience of being located within minutes of Governor's Harbour, the provincial capital, Buttonwood Reserve offers the tranquility of a remote beach-side location. SUCCESSFUL TURNKEY RENTAL PROGRAM Buttonwood Reserve is structured provide owners of these luxurious vacation condominiums with positive economics, while minimizing day-to-day management hassle for owners:Each condominium is individually owned. The property and the Rental Program are managed by the Buttonwood Reserve Condominium Association (HOA), and 100% of the earnings from the Rental Program are distributed to condo owners. Rental performance to date has been strong, and net proceeds (after all costs are taken into account) have been consistently and significantly positive. FUTURE PLANS When completed, Buttonwood Reserve will comprise a total of eight buildings (32 condominium units), of which two are already completed. All eight buildings will enjoy the unique two-ocean view that makes the property so stunning today.The development is well capitalized and has been financed without external debt, so it does not carry the risks that sometimes plague multi-year real estate projects. APPRECIATION POTENTIAL Condo owners at Buttonwood Reserve will enjoy a luxurious, high-end vacation resort for personal enjoyment, short term cash flow and, over time, increased property value as the island continues to develop. Property appreciation is expected to be especially important for owners who invest in the early stages of the development plan, as Buttonwood Reserve continues to develop its reputation as full-service resort complex in the years to come.

To help protect your payment, always use our platform to send money and communicate with hosts.

$ 0/ night

More from this host

More rentals from this host

All rentals by Matthew Simon
New Condo w/Htd Pool, Private Beach, 2-Ocean View, Golf Cart, AS SEEN ON HGTV

New Condo w/Htd Pool, Private Beach, 2-Ocean View, Golf Cart, AS SEEN ON HGTV

Eleuthera

New Penthouse Condo w/ 2-Ocean View, Private Beach, Dock, Pool, Golf Cart

New Penthouse Condo w/ 2-Ocean View, Private Beach, Dock, Pool, Golf Cart

Eleuthera

Private and Secluded Beachfront House on Deserted Pink-Sand Beach

Private and Secluded Beachfront House on Deserted Pink-Sand Beach

Eleuthera

Secluded Beachfront Estate, 9 Acres & 725' of Private Frontage NEW HTD POOL!

Secluded Beachfront Estate, 9 Acres & 725' of Private Frontage NEW HTD POOL!

Eleuthera

Nearby stays

Other places to stay close by

Luxuriously Restored Historic Hilltop Estate with Harbor & Ocean views

Luxuriously Restored Historic Hilltop Estate with Harbor & Ocean views

Eleuthera

Stylish Cottage w/ Private Pool and Grounds, Walk to Town, Beach

Stylish Cottage w/ Private Pool and Grounds, Walk to Town, Beach

Eleuthera

Luxuriously Restored Historic Hilltop Estate with Harbor & Ocean views

Similar properties

Comparable rentals you might like

Secluded Beachfront Estate, 9 Acres & 725' of Private Frontage NEW HTD POOL!

Secluded Beachfront Estate, 9 Acres & 725' of Private Frontage NEW HTD POOL!

Charming and Affordable House in Prime French Leave Beach Location

Charming and Affordable House in Prime French Leave Beach Location

Historic Beach House with Pool, Spectacular Ocean Views

Historic Beach House with Pool, Spectacular Ocean Views

Luxuriously Restored Historic Hilltop Estate with Harbor & Ocean views

Eleuthera

Exotic Island Villa with Harbour View and Private Pool

Exotic Island Villa with Harbour View and Private Pool

Eleuthera

Romantic, luxurious cottage with stylish comtemporary decors, ocean views.

Romantic, luxurious cottage with stylish comtemporary decors, ocean views.

Eleuthera

Restored Historic Waterfront Captains Home, Sunset Views, Walk to Beach

Restored Historic Waterfront Captains Home, Sunset Views, Walk to Beach

Eleuthera

Magnificent 9-Bedroom Beachfront Compound w/ Private Pool French Leave Beach

Magnificent 9-Bedroom Beachfront Compound w/ Private Pool French Leave Beach

Shangri-La, Bahamas Tropical Beach Villa, Atlantic Ocean

Shangri-La, Bahamas Tropical Beach Villa, Atlantic Ocean

Private 5-bedroom Beachfront Estate w/Heated Pool on Pink Sand Beach

Private 5-bedroom Beachfront Estate w/Heated Pool on Pink Sand Beach